The key question: who owns your data?
Before we compare features, the most important question: where is your company data stored, and who has access to it?
With OneDrive, your files are stored on Microsoft's servers — in the USA or in European data centres, but always within a US corporate structure. The US CLOUD Act obliges Microsoft to give US authorities access to this data on request — regardless of where the servers are physically located.
With Nextcloud on your own server in Germany or Switzerland, no US corporation is involved in hosting your data – control over the data lies with you.
The big comparison — feature by feature
| Area | Microsoft OneDrive | Nextcloud (self-hosted) |
|---|---|---|
| Data storage | US servers, CLOUD Act | Your server in DE/CH |
| GDPR / revFADP | Risk due to the CLOUD Act | Designed with them in mind, data in DE/CH |
| Licence costs | from €5/user/month (Plan 1) | €0 — open source |
| Storage space | 1 TB/user (Plan 1) | Unlimited (own server) |
| File synchronisation | ✓ Desktop & mobile | ✓ Desktop & mobile |
| File sharing | ✓ Full-featured | ✓ Full-featured, incl. expiry date |
| Office in the browser | ✓ Microsoft 365 | ✓ Collabora / OnlyOffice |
| Calendar & contacts | ✓ Outlook integration | ✓ CalDAV/CardDAV (all clients) |
| Video conferencing | ✓ Teams (separate) | ✓ Nextcloud Talk (integrated) |
| Mobile apps | ✓ iOS & Android | ✓ iOS & Android |
| Own domain | ✗ Always a Microsoft URL | ✓ cloud.ihrefirma.ch |
| Extensibility | Microsoft ecosystem only | 200+ apps & plugins |
| Vendor dependence | Complete (subscription required) | None — open source |
What OneDrive really costs
Microsoft often presents OneDrive costs as part of Microsoft 365. Billing is per user per month – depending on the plan (Business Basic, Standard or Premium), the amount grows with every additional workstation. Microsoft lists the current prices on its website.
In addition: as a customer, you have no influence on future price changes.
How does migrating from OneDrive to Nextcloud work?
The migration is technically simpler than many people think. The biggest challenge is not the technology — it is the employees' habits.
- Step 1: set up Nextcloud on Swiss or German servers
- Step 2: transfer all files and folders from OneDrive to Nextcloud
- Step 3: install the Nextcloud desktop client on all devices
- Step 4: synchronise calendars and contacts via CalDAV/CardDAV
- Step 5: staff training — in our experience this takes 1–2 hours
- Step 6: cancel the OneDrive subscription
The entire migration typically runs in parallel without interrupting operations — OneDrive is only deactivated once everything is running.
Frequently asked questions about Nextcloud vs. OneDrive
Is Nextcloud as easy to use as OneDrive?
Yes — from the user's point of view the difference is minimal. The Nextcloud desktop client works just like OneDrive: folders synchronise automatically, and files can be shared with a right-click. The web interface is more modern and clearer than OneDrive's. After a short familiarisation period (typically 1–2 days), most employees report no longer noticing any difference in everyday work.
What about SharePoint — can Nextcloud replace that too?
For most SME use cases, yes. Nextcloud offers team folders, group permissions, comments and collaborative editing. What Nextcloud does not offer is SharePoint's very deep Microsoft integration (Power Automate, Power Apps etc.). For companies that use SharePoint as a simple document management system, Nextcloud is a full replacement.
Can I open Word and Excel files directly in Nextcloud?
Yes. With Collabora Online or OnlyOffice (both can be integrated into Nextcloud), you open and edit .docx, .xlsx and .pptx directly in the browser. Real-time co-editing by several users is also possible. The files remain in Microsoft format and can easily be shared with customers and partners who use Office.
Do I need to buy my own server, or is rented hosting enough?
Rented hosting is entirely sufficient. For Swiss customers, we recommend Hosttech with servers in Wädenswil (ZH) and Nottwil (LU) — for 5–20 users, a small virtual server is usually enough. No server of your own needed, no hardware of your own, no on-site maintenance. We set everything up and take care of updates.
What is the difference between Nextcloud and OpenCloud?
Nextcloud is the more established, more widely used solution with a larger community and more extensions. OpenCloud is a more modern alternative with a faster architecture and a cleaner interface — developed by a German team. For most SMEs we recommend Nextcloud. For companies that value the latest technology, OpenCloud is an interesting alternative. We will advise you in the initial consultation.
Replacing OneDrive — get free advice
We set up Nextcloud or OpenCloud on Swiss or German servers — designed with the revFADP in mind, without monthly licence costs, in person on-site in Switzerland.
Topics
- Linux & Open Source
- Switzerland & revFADP
- CLOUD Act
- Data protection
- Microsoft 365
- Nextcloud
- Open Source
- revFADP
- Switzerland
